I never paid Trent Horne, formerly of Catholic Answers any attention. I think the last time I looked at Catholic Answers may have been back when my husband was going through RCIA. However, I do know who the man is and when he left the organization. He posted a video on his YouTube channel asking for help, that is, donations to boost his Counsel of Trent channel. He has a sick wife and three small children and his mother passed away. It's been a hell year. He says he can't get a job working for some other Catholic organization because he'd have to give up his podcast and getting himself established and taking care of his wife is expensive and so he's forced to ask for help.
Well, Chris Jackson took a look at the publicly available financial records of Catholic Answers and guess what? Mr. Horne made $175K last year. That's not chicken feed and it's above the $87K income of the average American household. If Mr. Horne wants people to donate to him, he has to swallow his pride and be frank about his financial difficulty. On paper he's not living in genteel poverty and it looks ugly and shameless to beg from kindhearted folks, unless he's in dire straits. He's not asking for medical bill money or saying that he's worried about losing his house or car.
My first thought was that joining the ranks of Trad or just Catholic Inc. is a really good living. I've long been distrustful of laypeople who make their money off the Faith and I've noticed that these people live rather large. We all see the videos and photos that professional Catholic "influencers," publish showing fine homes in the country, dinner receipts, trips to Europe, ostensibly for pilgrimages and the endless conferences with those lovely speaker fees. Why exactly should I give my charity money to these people instead of my local cloistered nuns or the parish food bank or to support the diocesan free clinic?
A man or woman who has a family, a mortgage, tuition and a hundred other things and people depending on them is going to be very careful about not offending the big money donor or do anything to risk their access to the right high ranking clergyman. You can't really trust them to speak out in bad times if it means shrinking their wallet. I've said it before. Don't go to influencers for spiritual guidance. We have the Bible, the Catechism, the Church Fathers, the writing of saints, and if you are blessed, you have a good parish priest.